New recipes

Restaurant Critic Roundup: Small Place, Big Ambitions

Restaurant Critic Roundup: Small Place, Big Ambitions

We are searching data for your request:

Forums and discussions:
Manuals and reference books:
Data from registers:
Wait the end of the search in all databases.
Upon completion, a link will appear to access the found materials.

Every week, The Daily Meal rounds up restaurant reviews across America

As always, the ratings range from stars to bells to beans, but every review offers specialized insight into the food, atmosphere, and service of eateries in each city’s dining scene and the critics eating at them.

This week, The Daily Meal presents our first annual "Top Chefs Review — and Rate — America's Food Critics," where we polled dozens of the nation’s most notable chefs and restaurateurs and asked them to vote on America's best known critics (take that for a flip side). This critics' scorecard involves 20 critics, rated on a restaurant review scale of zero to four stars (four being a glowing review) based on four criteria: culinary knowledge, prose style, integrity (perceived), and likability. Even better, participants could actually critique critics and writers. So, "which critics do chefs think don’t know kimchi from kombu?" writes executive editor Arthur Bovino. You can read to find out.

Back in the world of critics ranking the chefs, New York's Pete Wells admits to going "wobbly with happiness" for a bowl of lentils "at a quiet Indian restaurant in the East 60s called Moti Mahal Delux."

In San Francisco, restaurant Hopscotch is hailed as "a study in contrasts." "It's a small place," critic Michael Bauer says, "but it has big ambitions."

In Washington, D.C., "Fuego Cocina y Tequileria was born... with some serious heat in its belly," boasting "a fire" that can be seen on plates, felt in the air, and served with a warning.

From the East Coast to the West Coast, from North to South, the weekly restaurant critic roundup is here for all of your dining out needs.

Restaurant Critic Roundup: 12/5/2012

Devra FirstThe Boston GlobeMistral3 stars
Ryan SuttonBloombergHearth3 stars
Michael KaminerThe New York Daily NewsThe Odeon
Pete WellsThe New York TimesMoti Mahal Delux2 stars
Michael BauerThe San Francisco ChronicleHopscotch3 bells
Candy SagonThe Washington PostFuego Cocina y Tequileria2 stars
William PorterThe Denver PostThe Universal3 stars

Check last week's Restaurant Critic Roundup.

Tyler Sullivan is The Daily Meal's assistant editor. Follow her on Twitter at @atylersullivan.

This Man Wants to Remind Indonesia That Food Comes From the Earth, Not an App

Bumi Langit is more than a mere restaurant to owner Iskandar Waworuntu. It&aposs a physical representation of his entire philosophy on food and the earth—one that was distilled after years of traveling throughout Indonesia to learn about farming, permaculture, and the natural balance of the ecosystem in the country&aposs fields and paddies, not the classroom.

"Farming is a way of living that involves every kind of aspect of your life," Pak Is, as his friends call him, told me. "Food is the most fundamental aspect of life. You are what you eat."

The restaurant, which is located about 20 kilometers from downtown Yogyakarta in the hills of Imogiri, was more crowded than usual when I arrived. Former US President Barack Obama had just eaten lunch at the spot a few days earlier during his post-presidency holiday in Indonesia. Obama&aposs visit helped Bumi Langit achieve a level of popularity not usually bestowed on restaurants that come with their own credo and a commitment to organic farming—outside Bali&aposs yoga and spiritualism mecca of Ubud, of course.

The newfound popularity was a windfall for a traditionally minded restaurant that serves old-school Javanese food. But it was also a lot of work for a place that hosts educational tours for school children and runs its own organic, permaculture farm as well.

"I feel very humbled by the Obama&aposs visit," Pak Is told me. "Now the restaurant has become more crowded, so I have to be careful."

Bumi Langit is one of the pioneers of permaculture in Indonesia. The agriculture practice, which works with the land in its natural state to create a more holistic form of farming, is slowly gaining traction in Indonesia𠅊 country that before independence was a mostly agrarian nation. Today, agriculture employs more than 40 percent of the total workforce, and is responsible for more than 14 percent of the Gross Domestic Product. But a lot of that workforce labors on large-scale industrial palm oil, coffee, and pulpwood plantations owned by multinational corporations.

Pak Is is talking about a more down-to-earth homestead kind of farming here. Back in 1995, Pak Is, then a teenage boy, dropped out of school and embarked on a journey through Java and Sumatra to learn as much as he could about permaculture farming. He told me that the only way to learn how to actually farm was on the farms themselves. The skills he learned on the road𠅊nd the self-discovery𠅌ould never be found in a classroom, Pak Is told me.

When he returned to Jogja, Pak Is took a job at Bengkel Teater, which was founded by the city&aposs famed activist, writer, and director WS Rendra. Pak Is told me that he enjoyed the work, but he couldn&apost shake his love of farming. Permaculture was his true passion, he said. Pak Is sees farming as a self-sustaining economic model, one that isn&apost trapped in the typically exploitative systems of capitalism and world trade.

He found three acres of land in the Imogiri hills outside downtown Jogja in 2006 and established the Bumi Langit community. Initially, people laughed at Pak Is. His land was barely fertile, and the whole endeavor seemed destined to fail. Pak Is wasn&apost born into a family of farmers, and few had time for a city guy who came down to Imogiri with all these ideas about "holistic farming."

But Pak Is drilled deep wells and used the permaculture techniques he learned on the road to make the ground fertile. His farm tried to limit the use of chemicals, composted excess food and organic scrap, and turned animal manure into biogas. By the time Pak Is opened his own restaurant, the locals weren&apost laughing anymore.

Pak Is took the ethics of his farm further, taking a similar approach to his own life. He never uses plastic, makes his own soaps, and keeps his farm off the electrical grid. Most of the time, Bumi Langit uses solar power. But during the rainy season, when the skies are dark with clouds, the farm still needs to rely on a diesel generator, he admitted.

He offered to show me around his farm. Bumi Langit is a beautifully natural place. The farm is surrounded by the forest. The buildings are constructed in traditional Javanese architecture out of wood grown specifically for the house so that they doesn&apost tax the nearby forests. The farmland itself is built out of irrigated terraces. Chickens wander free range everywhere. A pond of fish sat next to some of the vegetables.

The whole place looked like an idyllic farm, aside from the fact that I didn&apost see that many people around working. Pak Is told me that Bumi Langit wasn&apost able to produce the same amount of food as a larger, more industrial farm. He kept things small and manageable to maintain the ethics of the place.

"We&aposre in a state where we&aposre not in charge of our food," he explained. "We no longer know where our food comes from. We have become more dependent on the industry."

Pak Is opened the Bumi Langit restaurant in 2014 on the advice of a friend who said he felt bad always eating Pak Is&apos food without paying for it. It&aposs far from one of the most-popular spots in Jogja𠅊 city with a rich culinary scene and a steady stream of new tourists. It&aposs also far from expensive. The 12-person Obama party ate for less than Rp 4 million ($298 USD)—or about $24 USD a person for a totally organic handmade meal. It&aposs more pricy than a meal at the local warung, but still far less than a fancy meal at one of the city&aposs trendy tourist spots.

I stopped to eye the menu on the way out the door. They were serving Ayam Goreng Bahagia and Ayam Geprek Kecombrang. I chose the second dish, eating perfectly fried chicken with kecombrang flowers that are apparently good for your health. I then ate fruit jam kefir and mango ice cream made from pure coconut milk for dessert.

For a brief moment I felt like Obama. And that&aposs not half bad.


By signing up to the VICE newsletter you agree to receive electronic communications from VICE that may sometimes include advertisements or sponsored content.


  1. Gardaramar

    I confirm. I join told all above. Let's discuss this question.

  2. Howard

    I want to encourage you to look at

  3. Nikogul

    You were visited with simply excellent idea

  4. Gashakar

    The blog is just great, I will recommend it to my friends!

Write a message